Why Puppy Toys Are Essential

Puppies explore the world with their mouths. The right toys can:

• Soothe Teething Pain: Specialized chew toys provide relief for sore gums.

• Prevent Destructive Behavior: By giving your pup an appropriate outlet for chewing, you save your shoes, furniture, and belongings.

• Provide Mental Stimulation: Puzzle toys fight boredom and prevent anxiety.

• Aid in Training: Toys are powerful rewards for positive reinforcement training.

• Encourage Exercise: Active play helps burn off that boundless puppy energy.

Types of Puppy Toys and Their Benefits

1. Chew Toys & Teethers

These are arguably the most important toys for a new puppy. They are designed to be durable and safe for intense chewing, often with textures that massage sore gums.

• Best for: Teething puppies (3-6 months), aggressive chewers.

• Top Pick:
  KONG Puppy Toy

  • Why it’s great: Made from a softer, gentler rubber that’s perfect for puppy teeth. You can stuff it with kibble or a treat (like a dab of peanut butter) to keep your pup engaged for hours. It’s a classic for a reason.

2. Interactive & Puzzle Toys

These toys challenge your puppy’s brain by making them work for a treat. They are excellent for mental exercise and can help with slow feeding.

• Best for: Mental stimulation, curbing boredom, intelligent breeds.

• Top Pick:
  Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel Puzzle Toy

  • Why it’s great: This plush puzzle tree comes with squeaky squirrels that your puppy has to pull out. It satisfies their natural prey drive and keeps them thinking. It’s a huge hit with most puppies.

3. Plush & Squeaky Toys

Soft, cuddly, and often featuring enticing squeakers, these toys are perfect for comfort and interactive play like fetch and tug-of-war.

• Best for: Gentle chewers, comfort, play and fetch.

• Top Pick:
  GoDog Plush Toys with Chew Guard Technology

  • Why it’s great: These are not your average plush toys. They are specifically designed with reinforced seams and durable materials to withstand more chewing than typical stuffed toys. Plus, they come in adorable designs.

4. Rope & Tug Toys

Great for interactive play between you and your pup, rope toys also help clean teeth and massage gums as your puppy chews.

• Best for: Dental health, playing tug, interactive play.

• Top Pick:
  Mighty Paw Naturals Braided Rope Toy

  • Why it’s great: Made from 100% natural cotton, it’s perfect for a game of tug and helps floss your puppy’s teeth as they chew. Always supervise play with rope toys.

Key Features to Look For in a Safe Puppy Toy

1. Size Appropriateness: The toy should be large enough that it can’t be swallowed whole or become a choking hazard.

2. Durability: Look for toys labeled specifically for “puppies” or “light chewers” initially. Upgrade to “strong chewers” options as your pup grows.

3. Material Safety: Avoid toys with toxic materials, loose parts, buttons, or easily detached squeakers that can be swallowed.

4. Supervision is Key: No toy is 100% indestructible. Always supervise your puppy during playtime to ensure they are using the toy safely.

Puppy Toy Safety: A Quick Checklist

• Inspect Regularly: Check toys daily for signs of wear and tear, such as rips, loose pieces, or stuffing coming out. Throw away damaged toys immediately.

• Match to Chew Strength: A toy for a Labrador puppy will be different than one for a Chihuahua puppy. Choose accordingly.

• Avoid Hard Materials: Stay away from extremely hard toys like antlers or hard nylon bones that can fracture puppy teeth.

Top Recommendations: The Best Puppy Toys of 2025

1. Best All-Around Toy: KONG Puppy Toy
   The ultimate stuffable, chewable, bouncy toy that satisfies a wide range of needs. A must-have for every puppy owner.
   Shop KONG Puppy Toys on Amazon

2. Best for Teething: Nylabone Puppy Chew Teething Keys
   These soft, textured keys are easy for tiny puppy mouths to grip and chew on, providing targeted relief for sore gums.
   Buy Nylabone Teething Keys on Amazon

3. Best Puzzle Toy: Outward Hound Nina Ottosson Dog Brick Puzzle
   A step-up in difficulty, this puzzle has multiple compartments and sliders for your puppy to solve to get to the treats.
   Find Outward Hound Puzzles on Amazon

4. Best for Fetch: Chuckit! Ultra Ball Small
   These bright, durable rubber balls are perfect for a game of fetch indoors or out. They are bouncy and easy for puppies to see and carry.
   Get Chuckit! Balls on Amazon

Final Thoughts: Rotate and Engage

The best puppy toys are safe, engaging, and suited to your pup’s individual needs. Don’t just give them all at once! Rotating toys every few days keeps things fresh and exciting for your puppy.

Most importantly, use toys to bond with your new family member. Playtime is training time and a chance to build a lifelong connection.

Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. This means that if you make a purchase after clicking on one of our links, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support our work and allows us to continue providing valuable content for pet owners. We only recommend products we have confidence in and believe will benefit our readers.